Make it Naked

Banana Peanut Butter


So are the kids in bed? It’s totally a school night. I thought I’d help and make them lunch. Well, not really. But you get it. Two slices of bread and this peanut butter and you’re done.  Maybe toss an apple in the lunch box. Or some string cheese. Since it’s the first day, you should probably write an embarrassing note on a napkin. I totally would.

Really, who doesn’t love a peanut butter and banana sandwich? It’s only one of the best combinations ever. But here’s the thing. Bananas are always so unripe in the grocery store. Unripe bananas taste like green. They’re so bitter and hard and you have to wait days for them to be edible. Gross. My perfect banana is completely yellow with just a few freckles. So I wait. I wait and the whole time I have a bunch? a group? a cluster? a bundle? whatever, I have a lot of bananas staring at me wanting to be slathered in peanut butter.  Waiting for banana perfection is stressful. So I handled it.

To make the best peanut butter ever, all you need is 5 ingredients. I took freeze dried bananas and processed them into a powder. Be careful when you open the processor or blender at this point. I inhaled quite a bit of banana powder. It reminded me of Fun Dip. Delicious homemade banana Fun Dip. You could find a tasteless, chalky, candy stick and stop here, but I added some roasted peanuts and continued to process. Problem solved. Put the banana right in the butter and wait no more. After a short time processing you’re left with a creamy, naturally sweet, banana-y spread. A fun twist to your kids’ lunches this school year. That is, if you want to share. They’ll never know if you keep it to yourself and send them with last night’s leftovers.

Hope you had a happy Labor Day!

Banana Peanut Butter

70g (2.5oz) freeze dried bananas
1lb (16oz) roasted, unsalted peanuts
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon


  1. In a food processor or very strong blender, process the dried bananas until powder.
  2. While they’re processing, roast the peanuts as I explain in this post.
  3. When the bananas are completely powder, add in the roasted nuts, vanilla, salt and cinnamon.
  4. Let process until creamy. This can take 10-20 minutes. If you feel like your machine needs a break. Turn it off and let it sit for a while. Let it finish processing later. It can sit as long as you need it to sit. Scrape out of processor into a jar. Store in pantry. No need to refrigerate, although you may if you’d like.


  1. I think sweetening this with maple syrup or honey would be great but Jon and I both like our peanut butter unsweetened so I left it out. I’d add a tablespoon at a time until you reach your desired sweetness.
  2. I got my freeze dried bananas at Trader Joe’s. Can you use real bananas? I’m sure you can…but wait till they’re ripe :) I’ve also seen this brand around town.
  3. I used Mexican vanilla because I’m in love but regular vanilla will work just fine.
  4. I froze some into little bites like I did here.  Still one of my favorite pre-workout snacks.
  5. Other fun nut butters from MiN:
    *coconut cashew butter
    *pecan butter
    *clementine cashew butter

14 thoughts on “Banana Peanut Butter

  1. I AGREE CUZ! I hate green bananas. However, this looks delicious. I wouldn’t expect anything less for you and your awesome culinary skills. I will have to try this. Seth is obssessed with peanut butter. Maybe I could even surprise him with it.

  2. Just a note to any “Pregnancy brains” out there. Be sure to take the non-eatable packet out of the TJs bag before you process the bananas…plan b was to use two bananas but the consistency was not right. It was totally a bummer but I will try again soon. Love the idea of this combo!

    • OH no! That’s terrible! What was wrong with the real bananas? Was it too lumpy? thick? How long did you process it with the real ones? I need to try it with real bananas and report back.

  3. I processed for the full 20 minutes. It ended up looking a lot like dark brown sugar in the end. Maybe the bananas were too wet & should’ve been added after processing the peanuts?

  4. Pingback: Make your own banana peanut butter. It’s redonkulous! | Geekation: where geeks go

  5. Pingback: Homemade Marshmallows (Vanilla, Strawberry, Orange and Mocha) | Make it Naked

  6. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  7. Pingback: Apple Cinnamon Almond Butter | Make it Naked

  8. Pingback: Lemon Energy Bites | Make it Naked

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Posted on September 3, 2012

Recent Recipes

Recipes by Category